Counselors not part of one California district’s plan to tackle student mental health
Alison Yin for EdSource

University student psychological well being was declining even ahead of the pandemic, investigate has proven.

Faced with escalating student mental health and fitness wants, a single California faculty district is making an attempt an unusual new method – one particular that does not contain counselors.

Saugus Union School District in northern Los Angeles County, which in current yrs has endured a nearby school shooting, wildfires and rising political polarization, is eliminating all 4 of its counselor positions and changing them with social staff. In the fall, the district will have nine social workers and no counselors.

The strategy is that social personnel are greater properly trained to tackle some root brings about of university student panic and despair, this kind of as poverty and other hardships that lie past the classroom, explained Superintendent Colleen Hawkins. They are also more expert in doing the job specifically with households and connecting them to local community expert services, she mentioned.

“Our counselors were being really worthwhile in the course of Covid, but now we’re again in college and we’re experiencing diverse issues,” Hawkins stated. “We appeared at the knowledge and made the decision we require to choose a a lot more systemic approach to the broader troubles our pupils and family members are experiencing.”

Saugus Union is a middle-course elementary district in Santa Clarita, with superior test scores and powerful family members involvement. But occasions in modern yrs have taken a toll on the district’s 10,000 pupils. In Oct 2019, the Tick and Saddleridge fires pressured hundreds to evacuate and the district to close campuses.

The up coming thirty day period, a student opened hearth at Saugus Large School, killing two classmates and wounding three other individuals before killing himself. Saugus Higher is not in the elementary district, but quite a few college students had older siblings at Saugus High, and the victims experienced attended Saugus elementary universities.

Then in March 2020, Covid forced the closure of faculty campuses nationwide. Saugus schools were being fairly early to reopen, but a politically divided local community has meant that protests from both equally sides are common.

Learners are dealing with the gamut of feelings from these events, reported Tonya Nowakowski, the district’s university student guidance providers coordinator and a social worker. Stress and anxiety and melancholy have elevated, alongside with self-hurt, having disorders, suicidal ideas and inappropriate habits in class, such as throwing issues or refusing to sit down.

“Mental health troubles can come about to any person. It cuts across all socio-financial and class boundaries,” Hawkins stated. “That’s why it’s so critical we establish networks to enable our learners and their households be resilient in the facial area of tragedy.”

But counselors say that students’ spike in psychological health and fitness requires is proof that the district should really increase its counseling staff members, not eliminate it. Although Saugus’ school counselors commit some of their time tending to tutorial problems, most of their times are expended on mental well being jobs: conference a single-on-1 with college students, chatting to classes, working with modest groups, visiting households at residence and consulting with teachers. Some have long-standing relationships with pupils and people who’ve shed cherished kinds to Covid or experienced other traumas.

Dismantling the counseling system will only damage individuals pupils further more, they explained.

“It’s devastating,” claimed Bridgette Martinez, who’s been a counselor in Saugus since 2016. “How am I likely to tell these students who’ve already missing so much, and gone by means of so significantly upheaval, that they’re heading to reduce this, far too? It’s a betrayal to our learners.”

The district’s counselors strongly protested the layoffs, with backing from the California Association of School Counselors and the American Civil Liberties Union of Southern California. Equally argue that counselors are vital on university campuses, specially now. They aim on social-psychological understanding, a person-on-a single behavioral providers and general campus local weather, among other duties intended to make pupils experience secure and welcome at college.

Like school social workers and psychologists, counselors have graduate-degree education in addressing students’ psychological well being wants. All three have pupil staff solutions credentials, although with distinct locations of specialization.

“School counselors are really sought-out psychological wellbeing professionals that give a scope of providers that other skillfully experienced psychological overall health provider vendors really don’t offer you,” mentioned Loretta Whitson, govt director of the California Association of School Counselors. “It can make no feeling for Saugus, at this essential time when mental health troubles are at an all-time substantial, to contemplate sunsetting their complete faculty counseling software. Not only does the Saugus selection conflict with finest practices and a long time of investigation on the effectiveness of college counseling, it also arrives through the important recovery period of the COVID-19 pandemic.”

Amir Whitaker, senior coverage counsel at the ACLU of Southern California, echoed Whitson’s sentiments. As opposed to counselors, university social employees don’t focus in addressing behavioral and mental health and fitness problems on a campuswide stage, which usually means that finally considerably fewer college students will benefit, he stated.

“The product Saugus is proposing has large holes that are pretty visible to any one who appears to be like at providing services to the broad range of needs in just a school environment,” Whitaker explained.

The condition does not call for universities to have any counselors, social employees or psychologists, but most have at the very least a several. Very last 12 months, Gov. Gavin Newsom and the Legislature poured millions into applications to bolster youth psychological wellbeing, which was declining in advance of the pandemic but dropped sharply when campuses closed. The condition is encouraging educational institutions to use their Covid relief funding to extend psychological health products and services and social-emotional studying, which include employing counselors, psychologists and social workers.

Continue to, California even now ranks toward the base of states nationwide in its counselor-to-university student ratio, at 1:601. Amongst college social employees, the ratio is even higher, at 1:6,000.

Saugus isn’t the only district that’s investing in social workers. Los Angeles Unified a short while ago employed 300 psychiatric social employees, bringing the district overall to 750. La Mesa-Spring Valley in jap San Diego County not long ago went from two to 16 social personnel. San Francisco Unified has 120 social workers, 15{7b6cc35713332e03d34197859d8d439e4802eb556451407ffda280a51e3c41ac} of all college social employees in the point out.

Still, they’re outnumbered by counselors in most districts. Los Angeles Unified, for case in point, has a lot more than 1,500 counselors in all.

Paul Brazzel, president of the California Association of University Social Staff, explained the Covid funding windfall has led to a hiring growth for school social employees in California.

But ideally, he said, social employees would not get the job done alone. They’d get the job done on a team of counselors and psychologists, every with their possess places of knowledge.

“In a great globe, educational institutions would choose a multidisciplinary method,” he said. “We’re all experienced to aid college students with psychological health and fitness wants.”

In the meantime, in Saugus, Martinez and her colleagues are making ready for their very last day of operate on June 10. Jody Bolde, a counselor for 7 years, mentioned she’ll skip the learners she’s been viewing one particular-on-just one, the monthly classroom classes, the tiny teams of college students she aids with social and emotional capabilities, and the numerous other learners and instructors she’s worked with in excess of the decades.

“I really like my job. This has been intestine-wrenching,” she mentioned. “I assume social employees are terrific, but I really don’t recognize why we equally just can’t be right here to help young ones.”

To get additional experiences like this just one, click on here to indicator up for EdSource’s no-price every day e mail on most up-to-date developments in education.